Nokta Simplex vs Competitors
For a fully waterproof detector under $400, the Nokta Simplex beats the Garrett ACE series and Fisher F22 on submersibility and value, and trades blows with the Minelab Vanquish, which counters with true multi-frequency. If you hunt wet ground and want the best all-round value, the Simplex is the pick; if you want multi-IQ performance, look at Minelab. Here is how they stack up.
Pros
- Fully submersible where most rivals are only rain-resistant
- Lighter carbon fiber build than many competitors
- Free firmware updates competitors often lack
- Excellent value in the sub-$400 class
Cons
- Single frequency vs Minelab's Multi-IQ
- Not as deep as flagship multi-frequency machines
Quick comparison
A qualitative look at how the main rivals compare on the points that matter most to buyers:
| Detector | Waterproofing | Frequency | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nokta Simplex | Fully submersible | Single frequency VLF | Value, water hunting, beginners |
| Garrett ACE 400 | Rain-resistant (coil submersible, not control box) | Single frequency VLF | Dry-land coin and relic hunting |
| Minelab Vanquish | Rain-resistant to fully waterproof by model | Multi-frequency (Multi-IQ) | All-terrain performance |
| Fisher F22 | Weatherproof, coil submersible | Single frequency VLF | Budget dry-land hunting |
Specifics vary by exact model and revision, so confirm the current spec of the unit you are considering.
Simplex vs Garrett ACE
Against the Garrett ACE 250, 400 and 400i, the Simplex's biggest advantage is that the whole detector is submersible, where the ACE control box is not fully waterproof. The Simplex is also lighter and ships with free firmware updates. One detectorist put it bluntly, saying the Garretts run on older technology and don't match the performance of the newer machines. The ACE line still has a loyal following and simple ergonomics, but for water work the Simplex is the clearer choice.
Simplex vs Minelab Vanquish
This is the closest fight. The Vanquish 440 and 540 bring Minelab's Multi-IQ multi-frequency technology, which can give an edge on mineralized ground and the beach. The Simplex answers with full submersibility, a lighter carbon build, a color screen on the Ultra and free updates. Owners often name both as the top choices in the sub-$400 class. Choose the Vanquish if multi-frequency matters most; choose the Simplex if waterproofing and value lead your list.
Simplex vs Fisher F22 and AT Pro, and final recommendation
The Fisher F22 is weatherproof with a submersible coil but not a full dive machine, so the Simplex again wins on water. The Garrett AT Pro is a capable all-terrain unit that is submersible but older and typically pricier. Overall, for most buyers wanting one affordable detector that does land and water, the Simplex is the best-rounded pick. If you have specific needs - true multi-frequency, or a proven relic machine - the Vanquish or AT Pro deserve a look. Read the full Simplex review and the family guide before deciding, and check the current price.
Specifications
| Brand | NOKTA DETECTION TECHNOLOGIES |
| Color | Black |
| NumberOfItems | 1 |
| Height | 52.0 inches |
| Length | 52.0 inches |
| Weight | 3.0 Pounds |
| Width | 25.0 inches |
| Feature | WATERPROOF metal detectors for adults: The Nokta Simplex Ultra boasts all new aesthetics, enhanced technical performance, and is fully waterproof up to 16 ft (5 m). |
| Feature | FULLY CARBON FIBER: Simplex Ultra is a solid product with its carbon fiber Shaft. The Simplex Shaft is very durable besides its aesthetic appearance. Shaft retracts down to 25'' (63 cm). Great for easy transport, storage as well as diving! |
| Feature | ONLINE FIRMWARE UPDATES: Stay up-to-date with firmware updates (via USB on PC) and get the most out of your detector. |
| Feature | Bluetooth headphones are not included in the package. |
| Feature | Lightweight (2.6 Ibs / 1.2 kg): Well balanced - Enjoy detecting for extended hours without fatigue. |
| Height | 52.0 Inches |
| Weight | 3.0 pounds |
| Feature | Handheld Metal Detector with Vivid COLOR LCD Screen: The high-resolution color LCD screen provides all the essential information you need right before your eyes. Our user-friendly interface ensures effortless access to settings and adjustments, making pinpointing targets hassle-free. |
| Feature | Metal Detector with Accessories: Thanks to the Accessory Package, you can meet all your needs. You will have a nice detection experience. Includes: Premium Digger, Carrying Bag, Finds Pouch |
Source: www.amazon.com
What owners say
Here is what detectorists say about this on public forums:
Nokta hands down! Garretts are running on old technology, are overpriced, and don't even come close to the level of performance that the new ... r/metaldetecting
Where to buy
This model shows up under several Amazon listings and bundles. Prices change often - compare the current options:
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Nokta Simplex better than the Garrett ACE 400?
For water hunting, yes - the Simplex is fully submersible while the ACE 400 control box is not. The Simplex is also lighter and gets free firmware updates. For dry-land-only use the two are closer, and ACE fans value its simplicity.
Simplex or Minelab Vanquish?
Pick the Vanquish for true multi-frequency (Multi-IQ) performance, and the Simplex for full waterproofing, lighter weight and free updates at a strong price. Both are widely regarded as top options under $400.
How does the Simplex compare to the Fisher F22?
The F22 is weatherproof with a submersible coil but not a full dive detector, so the Simplex has the clear edge if you plan to hunt in or under water.
Ready to check the latest price?
Check Price on Amazon